Should Brian Cashman be fired?

[twsalso]

[JDPNYY]

Yes.

Can we go go back in time and make this retroactive?

[hardrain]

A thousand times yes

[ojo]

I just can't escape the fact I don't want this guy anywhere near a Yankee rebuild/re-tooling. So, yes. Fire him.

[JDPNYY]

The problem I see here, though... Is that Hal will ask Randy Levine who to hire.

[fredgmuggs]

The entire organization needs an overhaul from top to bottom. Cashman is responsible for this mess. Time for him to say goodbye

[jpao89]

It isn’t like this guy hasn’t had his chances. Sometimes, a franchise just needs a change of leadership. Trying the same thing year on year and listening to Cashman give his end of season postmortem, monotone:

”I thought we had enough”

assessment is beyond old. And you know what? He will say the same thing this year and claim they players just had off years and they had bad luck with injuries, etc. He will proceed to make ZERO changes.

I have had enough of this freaking guy. ENOUGH!!!

[JL25and3]

That’s like asking if there should be world peace, or if Scarlett Johansson should go to bed with me. The answer in every case is yes, but none of those things are going to happen.

[Krall]

That’s like asking if there should be world peace, or if Scarlett Johansson should go to bed with me. The answer in every case is yes, but none of those things are going to happen.

What if you had to choose between world peace and Scarlett Johansson?

I really don't care anymore. If you make 50 polls about this topic the outcome will still be the same. Hal isn't firing him, us peasants much carry on with this heavy weight on our shoulders . If you want him fired the only hope here would be if Scarlett Johansson slept with him the controversy would be more than even Hal could bare.

[YFIB]

The problem I see here, though... Is that Hal will ask Randy Levine who to hire.

Levine is 66 - maybe it's time to really start fresh.

On the other hand, I could see Hal doing what the Celtics just did, and promoting Cashman and have him bring in a new GM and coach. Maybe he could put Gardner in one of those roles.

[Mixwell]

Immediately without hesitation

[Mixwell]

Levine is 66 - maybe it's time to really start fresh.

On the other hand, I could see Hal doing what the Celtics just did, and promoting Cashman and have him bring in a new GM and coach. Maybe he could put Gardner in one of those roles.

Theo Epstein isn't going to work for Brian Cashman

[JL25and3]

What if you had to choose between world peace and Scarlett Johansson?

I’d have to put a lot of thought into that choice, after I spent the night with Johansson.

[MyBoysKaosHavoK]

A- Yes
B- Yes
C- Yes
D- All of the above
E- Any part of Yes you don't understand?....

[Maynerd]

Four people have voted 'no.'

I am not among them. Enough is enough. Cashman needs to go, and he needs to take a bunch of people with him.